Two different kinds of picture
A bitmap records the colour at each point of a grid. A vector records shapes — outlines, and a fill for each. Logos, icons and illustrations are naturally made of shapes, so they convert to vectors with little loss. A photograph is not: a cheek is a smooth gradient of hundreds of tones, a lawn is thousands of tiny blades, a sky is a slow fade.
Any tracer, however clever, has to decide which shapes to draw. Draw too many and you get a file with tens of thousands of paths that is slower to open than the photo was. Draw too few and the subject becomes unrecognisable. The useful result lives in between, and it is always a stylisation.
The three controls that matter
- Number of colours
- Every colour is a set of shapes. Four to eight colours gives a bold poster; twelve to twenty-four gives a softer, more painterly look; beyond thirty the gains are small and the file grows quickly.
- Detail
- Sets the minimum region size and the curve tolerance. Low detail merges small regions into their neighbours and fits looser curves; high detail keeps small features.
- Style
- Smooth, Poster, Flat, Minimal, Detailed and Duotone each set colours, smoothing and region size together for a recognisable look.
A practical routine
- Crop. Every square centimetre of background you keep is detail you pay for.
- Remove or simplify the background. Subject only, using the on-device model, often makes the biggest difference of all.
- Press Compare three versions and pick the closest.
- Adjust colours first, detail second.
- Merge colours in Palette that read as the same tone, and remove specks in Edit.
Gradients become bands
A flat-fill vector cannot store a smooth gradient, so a sky becomes a set of horizontal bands. That is the single most visible effect of tracing a photo. More colours make the bands narrower and less obvious; fewer colours make them a feature. Many classic poster styles are built on exactly this look.
When a vector is the wrong choice
If you need the photo to look like a photo at a larger size, vectorizing is the wrong tool — a good upscaler is the right one. Vectorize a photo when you want a graphic: a print, a sticker, a stencil, a laser engraving, an illustration for a slide, a design that will be recoloured.